China’s Retaliation at Japan’s Interference in South China Sea

Japanese Foreign Minister Fumio Kishida (L) meets Chinese ambassador to Japan Cheng Yonghua in Tokyo, Japan, in this photo taken by Kyodo August 9, 2016. Mandatory credit Kyodo/via

It has been Japan’s earnest desire that the ruling of the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) will be entirely unfavorable to China as that will give China enough trouble in the South China Sea and help contain China’s rise. Japan sees China’s rise as a threat as no one can be sure that China will not retaliate the misery Japan caused to China when it invaded China. It has turned out that the ruling is entirely unfavorable, but China’s strong response that challenges the US to fight and US inaction has resulted in Chinese dominance of the South China Sea. Now, Chinese air force is conducting regular combat patrol of the South China Sea to scare rival claimants, especially the Philippines.

In order to further scare the Philippines and retaliate Japan’s interference with China’s disputes with the Philippines, China now takes counteroffensive in the East China Sea by sending an unprecedented large fleet of government ships to the sea areas near the disputed Diaoyu Islands (known as Senkakus in Japan) to provide protection China’s large fishing operation there.

What can Japan do in response?

Japan protests but China simply disregards the protests and stresses the islands and the water near them are China’s.

Reuters says that Japan has warned China of worsening ties over the dispute, but in the past the ties were deteriorated due to the dispute and Japanese Prime Minister Abe’s visit to Yasukuni Shrine. It was Japan that took the initiative to improve the ties while China simply does not care about that. Japan has lots of investment and interest in China. It will be Japan who suffers greatly from the deterioration of ties.

Comment by Chan Kai Yee on Reuters report, full text of which can be viewed below:

Japan warns China of worsening ties over East China Sea dispute

Japan warned China on Tuesday that ties were “deteriorating markedly” over disputed East China Sea islets, and China’s envoy in Tokyo reiterated Beijing’s stance that the specks of land were its territory and called for talks to resolve the row.

Tensions between Asia’s two largest economies have risen since Japan saw an increasing number of Chinese coastguard and other government ships sailing near the disputed islets, called Senkaku in Japan and Diaoyu in China, over the past few days.

Japanese Foreign Minister Fumio Kishida called in Chinese ambassador Cheng Yonghua for the second time since Friday and told him that China was trying to change the status quo unilaterally, a Japanese foreign ministry statement said.

It also said Kishida told Cheng that the environment surrounding Sino-Japanese ties was deteriorating markedly.

Cheng said after the meeting that he told Kishida the islands were an integral part of China’s territory and that the dispute should be resolved through diplomacy and dialogue.

“I told him that … it is natural that Chinese ships conduct activity in the waters in question,” he told reporters.

“I also told him both countries need to work on dialogue through diplomatic channels so as not to make things more complicated and escalated,” Cheng said.

Kishida summoned Cheng after the latest flare-up in tensions over dozens of Chinese vessels that sailed near the islands at the weekend. Cheng was also called in by Japanese Vice Foreign Minister Shinsuke Sugiyama on Friday.

The flurry of Chinese incursions into the waters follows a period of sustained pressure on China about its activities in the South China Sea, and Chinese criticism of what it saw as Japanese interference in that dispute.

The United States, its Southeast Asian allies and Japan have questioned Chinese land reclamation on contested islands in the South China Sea, particularly since an international court rejected China’s historic claims to most of that sea last month.

China has refused to recognise the court ruling on a case brought by the Philippines. Japan called on China to adhere to it, saying it was binding but Beijing warned Japan not to interfere.

Ties between China and Japan, the world’s second and third largest economies, have been plagued by the territorial row, the legacy of Japan’s wartime occupation of parts of China and regional rivalry.

(Reporting by Kiyoshi Takenaka and Nobuhiro Kubo; Editing by Chang-Ran Kim and Paul Tait)

---